
Comic Grading Scale Wall Chart — Printable PDF (US Letter + 11×17 Poster)
Quick Facts
- All 25 grades — 10.0 Gem Mint down to 0.5 Poor, on the standard 10-point scale
- A plain-language "what to look for" line for every grade — spine stress, corner blunting, colour breaks, staple condition, page quality
- Two editions included — US Letter for home printing and an 11×17 tabloid poster edition
- Plus two panels the grades alone don't tell you: Page Quality and Restoration
- Instant download — a digital product; nothing is shipped
The Scale, in Language You Can Use
Every grading conversation uses the same 25 grades — but the official definitions run to a terse line each, and "minor spine stress" means nothing until someone tells you what it looks like on an actual book. This chart fills that gap: every grade paired with a plain-language note on the defects that define it, so you can stand at a back-issue bin, look at the book in your hand, and land on a defensible grade in under a minute.
The Basis — and the Honest Limits
The chart follows the standard 10-point grading scale used across the hobby, and its notes are written in the defect vocabulary graders actually use: spine ticks and stress lines, corner blunting and rounding, bends that do or don't break colour, staple rust and migration, cover gloss and soiling, and page quality from White to Brittle.
Two honest limits, stated up front: this is an estimation aid for raw books, not a guarantee of any grading company's result — grading is subjective and done in hand, and no chart can certify a grade. And it is an independent Everything Comics reference — not affiliated with CGC or CBCS. One more calibration note: 9.9 and 10.0 are vanishingly rare in practice — 9.8 is about the ceiling for a raw book — but they are on the chart so the scale you learn is the complete one.
How to Read It
Start at the top and work down. The right grade for your book is the highest grade whose allowed defects still describe it — the first row where you have to say "no, mine is worse than that" is one row too high. Then check the two footer panels: page quality can pull a grade down on its own, and restoration changes value even when a book looks sharp.
What's on the Chart — All 25 Grades
| Grade | Condition | Grade | Condition |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10.0 | Gem Mint | 5.0 | Very Good / Fine |
| 9.9 | Mint | 4.5 | Very Good+ |
| 9.8 | Near Mint / Mint | 4.0 | Very Good |
| 9.6 | Near Mint+ | 3.5 | Very Good− |
| 9.4 | Near Mint | 3.0 | Good / Very Good |
| 9.2 | Near Mint− | 2.5 | Good+ |
| 9.0 | Very Fine / Near Mint | 2.0 | Good |
| 8.5 | Very Fine+ | 1.8 | Good− |
| 8.0 | Very Fine | 1.5 | Fair / Good |
| 7.5 | Very Fine− | 1.0 | Fair |
| 7.0 | Fine / Very Fine | 0.5 | Poor |
| 6.5 | Fine+ | ||
| 6.0 | Fine | ||
| 5.5 | Fine− |
Every grade above carries its own "what to look for" line on the chart itself — the gallery shows three rows word-for-word, and the zoom images let you read the chart at full size before you buy.
Page Quality panel: White → Off-White to White → Cream to Off-White / Cream → Tan → Brown → Brittle, and what each means for the book. Restoration panel: Slight (A) / Moderate (B) / Extensive (C) — and what each tier does to value.
Specifications
| Delivered files | 2 PDFs — no zip, they download individually |
|---|---|
| Home edition | grading-chart-printable-letter.pdf — US Letter, 1 page |
| Poster edition | grading-chart-poster-11x17.pdf — 11×17 in tabloid, 1 page |
| Content | Identical in both editions: 25 grades with notes + Page Quality and Restoration panels |
| File type | Vector PDF — the type stays crisp at either size |
How Delivery Works
- Check out as normal — no waiting, no shipping
- Your download links appear on the confirmation page and are emailed to you
- Print the Letter edition at home, or take the poster edition to any print shop with tabloid paper
How to Print
- Print at 100% / Actual Size — no scaling needed or wanted
- The Letter edition fits a standard 8.5 × 11 frame; the poster edition fits an 11 × 17 frame — pin either over your grading desk
- Heavier or matte stock reads best under desk lighting; it prints cleanly in colour and stays fully readable in black & white
FAQ
Is this CGC's official chart?
No. It is an independent reference built on the standard 10-point scale, written and designed by Everything Comics. It is not affiliated with CGC or CBCS.
Will it tell me exactly what grade my book will get?
No tool can — grading is subjective and done in hand. The chart is an estimation aid: it will get your raw books into the right neighbourhood and teach you the vocabulary graders use, which is what pre-submission screening actually needs.
Why include 9.9 and 10.0 if they are almost never awarded?
Because the scale is the scale. Leaving the top off would teach you a 23-grade system and leave you guessing where the boundary sits — they are here so the chart is complete.
Is the free Mini Chart enough for me?
For casually sorting decent raw books, the top 10 grades may do. The moment you are screening books for submission, pricing mid-grade keys, or reading wear below a 7.5, you need the other 15 — that is where most raw books actually live.
Is anything shipped to me?
No. This is an instant download — both PDF editions are delivered right after checkout.
Licence & Digital Policy
Licence: personal use. Print as many copies as your own collecting needs — desk, binder, con bag. Please don't share, resell or repost the files themselves — that's what keeps a small shop like this one going.
Digital policy: if a file arrives defective or corrupted, we replace it first — and refund you if no working replacement is possible. Delivered-and-working digital goods are otherwise final.
Keep Going
Not sure yet? The FREE Mini Chart covers the top 10 grades — grab it, pin it up, and come back for the other 15 when you need them.
Grading books to submit? The Vol. 2 Grader & Con Pack ($9.99) adds slab labels, a submission & pressing log and an insurance worksheet — the paperwork that goes with the grading.
START FREE, BUILD THE SYSTEM: the FREE Mini Chart is the free entry point to this chart — grab it, join the list for WELCOME15 (15% off your first box), and when you're ready for the full system, the Complete Set (Vol. 1 + Vol. 2) is $19.99 vs. $22.98 bought separately.
Real Buyer Proof — Earned, Not Invented
This shop does not publish invented testimonials or star averages we cannot verify. When a buyer tells us a kit worked, we ask permission, keep their exact words, and publish them here with their first name and what they collect.
Used this one? Reply to your order email with three short lines: (1) what you bought it for, (2) what happened when you used it, (3) what you would tell a collector who is hesitating like you were. No discount or gift for a review, ever — honest, specific words only, good or critical.
Before you buy — the short answers
- Every comic bagged & boarded.
- Not graded. Sold exactly as pictured; ask and we'll send more photos.
- Ships flat in a rigid mailer from Pocatello, Idaho.
- One copy of each — when it's gone, it's gone.
- Publisher
- Everything Comics
Every photo is of this exact copy. We point out every flaw we find and never assign a numeric grade.
Bagged & boarded, shipped flat between stiffeners from Pocatello, Idaho.
More to look at



